| What it insulates against | Ground conduction: heat pulled downward and away by contact with cold earth, concrete or a vehicle floor. | Air temperature: heat lost to the surrounding cold air through convection and radiation. |
| Effect without the other | A mat alone with no bag leaves you exposed to cold air and offers little warmth on its own. | A bag alone on cold ground compresses underneath you, losing most of its insulating loft exactly where you need it most. |
| Comfort | Cushions hips, shoulders and pressure points against hard or uneven ground, improving sleep quality. | Provides warmth but no cushioning; a thin bag on bare ground is still an uncomfortable, cold sleep. |
| Pack size and weight | Self-inflating mats pack down to roughly the size of a rolled towel and weigh 0.5 to 1.5kg. | A three-season bag compresses into a stuff sack but is generally bulkier and heavier, 1 to 2kg. |
| Typical emergency uses | Sleeping in a car overnight, camping on cold ground, an unheated room during a power cut with only a sofa or floor available. | Winter camping, a stranded car overnight, an unheated home during a prolonged power cut, an unplanned night outdoors. |
| Rating system | Rated by R-value or thickness rather than temperature, indicating how well it resists heat loss to the ground. | Rated by comfort and limit temperatures (EN/ISO 23537), indicating the air temperature range it is designed for. |
| Price band | Roughly £20 to £60 for a self-inflating camping mat. | Roughly £30 to £100 for a three-season sleeping bag, more for expedition-grade. |